[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [Strawbale] Convection in SB walls



Hello,

Thanks Desert David for correcting what I understood of our conversation.

I see no point in trying to reduce the convection in the correctly built and plasterd SB walls (where all the holes are correctly stuffed). Ok, there is some convection in fibrous insulation material; probably because they contain larger air spaces than 'normal' insulation materials . But we still have VERY well preforming walls so let's put our attention on other details that make a well preforming building. Also, including 'solutions' for imaginary problems often create new real problems.

As for the performance of SB combined with panels; rather drawing a final conclusion from 1 test (even if it were done by the best experts) or a gut feeling I feel  that it is a field where I would first like to see a lot more hard data. Adapting Bruce's book 'Design of SB Buildings' to french made me realize that thermal testing is a very complex thing. That mistakes (in the protocol, in comparing and in drawing conlusions) are easily made and the numbers that come out give us, at best, a very limited vision of thermal reality. Still, they are clues to a better understanding. And then there is the real world... Herbert, are there any pasif house buildings made with OSB and SB that live up to those expectations?

Thanks Carol for Jan Lacompte's paper (http://www.viking-house.ie/downloads/Lecompte%20paper_partial%20fill%20cavity%20walling.pdf)

I wish you all a nice day,

André - drowning in Cognac - de Bouter
France





Le 08/12/2010 23:59, Jan Hollan a écrit :

      
I've wondered what can be done about this. Convection needs height to
really get going so I wonder if some less permeable layer laid
horizontally between the layers of bales might reduce it some.
My guess is it makes it worse, in the wall. It is not a pleasant thought 
for me, as I have insulated this way (using cardboard or paper) one wall 
already. It is better to let the air flow along the wall, as it makes no 
harm. The more convection cells spanning the full width of the insulation 
layer, the worse.

The airflow/convection barrier should be perpendicular to the heat flux, 
like panes in the window. This is easy in roofspace insulation (two 
layers of small bales or many sheets of straw from jumbo bales). I'm doing 
it on walls as well, using one decimetre thick sheets from large bales put 
into a light wooden framework.

Some maths concerning that is deep within the list archive... March and 
April 2005. Something more on that is in Czech only,
             http://amper.ped.muni.cz/pasiv/slama/how_work.pdf

yours moderator and list almost-no-reader
  Jenik


____________________________________________________
    European strawbale building discussion list

Send all messages to:
Strawbale@amper....muni.cz

Archives, subscription options, etc:
http://amper.ped.muni.cz/mailman/listinfo/strawbale
____________________________________________________

Ce message entrant est certifie sans virus connu. Analyse effectuee par AVG - www.avg.fr Version: 9.0.872 / Base de donnees virale: 271.1.1/3304 - Date: 12/08/10 08:34:00